Mental Help Net
  •  
Grief & Bereavement Issues
Resources
Basic InformationMore InformationLatest NewsQuestions and AnswersBlog EntriesVideosLinksBook Reviews
Therapist Search
Find a Therapist:
 (USA/CAN only)

Use our Advanced Search to locate a therapist outside of North America.

Related Topics

Depression: Depression & Related Conditions
Family & Relationship Issues
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
Death & Dying

Allan Schwartz, Ph.D.Allan Schwartz, Ph.D.
Dr. Schwartz's Weblog

Let's Not Blame the Mentally Ill: The Tragedy at Virginia Tech

Allan N. Schwartz, LCSW, Ph.D. Updated: Apr 19th 2007

First, I want to direct everyone's attention to the excellent essay written by Dr. Dombeck about the tragedy at Virginia Tech. This canbe found at: Issues raised by the Blacksburg, VA massacre

As Dr. Dombeck correctly points out the first impulse after such tragic events is to find someone or something to blame. My concern is that people not blame either Koreans, or the mentally ill. There was a report in the newspaper today that the Korean community in the United States fears that they will be blamed and become targets of attack as a result of Mr. Cho's actions. That would be a tragic mistake akin to blaming all Virginia Tech students for getting in the way of the bullets that were fired. Equally preposterous is the idea that all mentally ill people are responsible for what happened in Virginia. The mentally ill are a particularly handy target for blame since they tend to be stigmatized as being insane and out of control. In actual fact the incidence of violence among those with psychotic illnesses is quite low.

This is why we have to be very careful not to form generalizations and create stereotypes both of which can be damaging to others. For example, all Arabs are not responsible for the World Trade Center attack of 9/11. In the same way, all Muslims are not extremist radicals who believe in the use of violence. Yet, after 9/11 there were Arab Americans who were attacked in the streets as though they had flown the planes into the twin towers and there were Sikhs who are not even Muslim who were attacked on the false belief that they were Arabic. Presumably, the people who committed these violent acts against those they believed are the enemy is normal, white Americans.

During my many years working in psychiatric hospitals and outpatient clinics I learned that those with mental illnesses such as Bipolar Disorder, Schizophrenia, Schizoaffective Disorder, Major Depression and all the other variations of these disorders are no more violent than anyone else. There are a select few who had histories of some violence, mostly in response to an auditory hallucination during a psychotic episode. In actuality, the incidence of violence among this population is lower than the average normal population. These people suffer from a serious brain disorder but in all other ways feel the same sense of sadness, happiness, love and anger that the rest of us feel. They have religious beliefs, a sense of conscience, of right and wrong, of justice and injustice and of fairness and unfairness. Once their symptoms are controlled with the correct medications they perform, feel and interact much like other people. Even when they are not on medication and are experiencing symptoms they are not a danger to anyone. In fact, it has been my experience that, on the whole, someone with a serious psychotic illness who is not medicated can be a greater danger to their self than to anyone else.

Those with mental illnesses are keenly aware of the stigma attached to that diagnosis. This stigma causes them great pain and their illness is a source of great embarrassment.

This web log is not meant to romanticize those with mental illness or to glorify what mental illness is all about. The mentally ill are just like everyone else in society. I have met some who are wonderful people and others who are unpleasant and mean spirited, just like anyone else. In other words, if they were freed of their illnesses they would be like the rest of us and that means that they would range in personality types and pleasantness. The major point is that they do not deserve the stereotyped images of them as dangerous murderers who should be shunned and avoided.

In reading about the tragedy at Virginia Tech and about the person who committed the atrocities please remember that this does not define mental illness or the mentally ill. Just as a reminder, normal people commit murders that they justify through their religious and political beliefs. Terrorists of all types are people selected to carry out their murderous deeds because they are normal, calm and convinced that what they are doing will save the world.

The way we think, what we think and the conclusions we reach can have serious consequences if those thoughts direct us to take unjust actions. Instead of engaging in blame, whether it is the mentally ill, Koreans, other minority groups in the United States, let us mourn the loss of life in Virginia and begin the process of healing.

As always, your opinions are welcome and encouraged.

 

Allan Schwartz, LCSW, Ph.D.

Readers who live in the Boulder, Colorado metro area, or in Southwest Florida may contact Dr. Schwartz for face-to-face consultation. He is also available for psychotherapy through Skype video for those who are not in Florida or Colorado. He can be reached via email at dransphd@aol.com for details.

    Reader Comments
    Discuss this issue below or in our forums.

    lets treat them as unique - baadjies m - Oct 27th 2008

    as much as each person is taken as unique. lets try to accomodate those who have mental disorders and also respect them as people with feelings.to be honest we are discriminating them in our society.i know some of them might be dangerous but lets try to help them rather than being too afraid of them as if they are aliens!  lets again stop exploitation of using them for our own benefit.for an example: slavery!

    One final thought... - EvilPoet - Apr 21st 2007
    Speaking without actually talking... Too bad NO ONE was really truly listening.

    i think - leslie - Apr 20th 2007

    well my thing is that pepole cant just say that it's a mental illness cause if you feel that you sould take out your anger on someonr and not you that's nwhat's going to happen people are not crazy they just dont think about what they be doing at the time until it happen then they want to say that they just blanked out and ani't nothing wrong with them.  that's what i think about it!

    psycho disease - ou - Apr 20th 2007
    actually i have psycho disease for 3 years now but i never do the bad things to harm any people but i still wonder how long this disease will get out of mylife and have the simple life like other people today i just pray to god to heal my disease if anyone that reads this comment have any suggestion please tell me i would be appreciate about that very much thank you.

    Just my two cents... - EvilPoet - Apr 19th 2007
    Having a mental illness is no different than having any other illness. Why people act differently towards it nowadays is beyond me. If I say heart disease runs on my dad's side of the family - people can relate. If I say mental illness runs on my mom's side of the family that is quite a different story. It's been my experience that the mere mention of the term mental illness can evoke a strong response - most of it quite negative. In my mind they are no different - both need to be addressed BEFORE they become bigger  problems. My ex-husband has diabetes, when my kids were little they were checked regularly for it. In my opinion, the same should apply to mental illness if it runs in a family. If the stigma was taken away it would help A LOT.

    Follow us on Twitter!

    Find us on Facebook!



    This website is certified by Health On the Net Foundation. Click to verify.This site complies with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health information:
    verify here.

    Powered by CenterSite.Net