| |
Basic InformationMore InformationLatest NewsQuestions and AnswersBlog EntriesMaking a Work Plan Work for YouHow to Stop Worrying3 Ways to Know If You’re Saying Yes Too Much3 Simple Shifts for a Stress-Free Holiday: A Busy Person's GuidePoetry as Pregnancy: When "The Shrink Rap™ on Mental Illness" Gives BirthWhy Are We So Busy?How to Get Out of a CrisisGive Yourself a Break!The Truth About StressLearn to Manage Your Stress ProactivelyThe Fastest Way to Boost Your MoodSlowing Your Life to Enjoy it More and Get More DoneThe Key to Overcoming ProcrastinationAntidote to Busy: 5 Simple Ways to Find Time for YouNatural SPEED: Stress Resiliency Shrink Rap™: Safe Stress Survival Strategies10 Things to Stop Caring About If You Want to Be HappierUsing Your "Free" Time to Enrich Your LifeIs Laughter Really the Best Medicine?Life is a Struggle - or Is It??The World of Work - Have We Got It All Wrong?Forms of EscapismRest in CenterBeware of Secondhand StressWhy Worry?Enjoy The Freedom Not ToSimple Tips for a Stress-Free HolidayHoliday Coping with ADHD Children Accept DifficultyThe Beauty of Saying "No"Maybe It's Time to Come Out of the ClosetLate Sociologist Warned About Multitasking's Effect on WellnessMeditation and AnxietyTypes of Stress and Their SymptomsWhy Do We Dread Sunday: The Power of Anticipation?The Six "R" Road to Burnout Recovery - Part V: The Final "R"s - Relating and Risk-TakingA Generational-Digital Diatribe: Still, Don’t Be Afraid to Pet the Dinosaur (aka “Dinos & Digits”)Feel The SupportThe Six "R" Road to Burnout Recovery - Part IV: The Next Two "R"s - Retreating & WritingStress and Anxiety: The Impact the Government Shutdown and The Fiscal Cliff Had on PeopleThe Missing Parent Syndrome (MPS): How Psychosocial Loss Impacts Adult Children & Strategies for Building Bridges and Reworking the Grief - Pt ISports, Fans and StressFive Ways to See a Problem in a New LightThe Six “R” Road to Burnout Recovery – Part III: The First Two Strategic “R”s – Running and ReadingStress, Anxiety and Mindfulness MeditationThe Six "R" Road to Burnout Recovery - Part II: The Stress Doc's Strategic Brain-Body Map Can Stress Diminish the Effects of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy?Be the Boss of Your Smartphone Personal Discovery as Burnout Recovery: An Intimate Story of Hell to Glory - Part IWork, Stress and HealthAre You Self-Blaming and Self-Critical?Defining and Defeating ProcrastinationThe Four Stages of Burnout: The Erosive Spiral - Shrink Rap™ VersionTo Escape the Box, Embrace ParadoxBuilding Stress Resilience and Organizational Hardiness Despite Doing "More with Less"A Cool Shower for Icing a Blame-ThrowerRelax, You're Going to be CriticizedOf Self-Hatred and Self-CompassionIs the Stress Carrier a Modern Day Vampire? - Part II Safe Stress Tools for Survivin TNT Heaven - Part IWhat You Should Know About How Stress Shapes the BrainDrop the LoadSleeping, Eating & Gaming, Oh My: The Blood Sugar-Blood Pressure-Out for Blood TriangleOne Strategy to Put Your Technology on a LeashIt's Not Just Whether You're Stressed - It's Whether You Think You're Stressed3 Ways to Stop Worry24/7 SPEED/Resiliency Shrink Rap™:Safe Stress Survival StrategiesThe Impact of Small Stresses in Daily LifeJournaling and Mental Health Can Stress Make You Fat?Stressed at Work? You're Not AloneOf Anxiety and Stress Strengthening Stress Resiliency and Brain Agility with Humor and Natural SPEEDTake Back Your Time: How to Reduce Overwhelm in a Few Minutes a DayBooster Breaks at Work: Hit or Bust?Overcoming Stress by Volunteering With Your DogBoston: Compassion During a Terrorist AttackAnger and Stress, Letting It All OutYour Body Under Stress: DNA, Cells and AgingWhat is Radical Acceptance Anyway?New Research Shows Chronic Stress Accelerates Alzheimer's DiseaseThe Power of Mindfulness for TeensDepression and Learned HelplessnessTake a Dip in PleasureCome to CenterStress and Shingles, Mind and Body are OneYour 14:57 Minute RuleCan Understanding Neuroscience Free Us from Downward Spirals?Is It Possible? Stress and The Older AdultOnline Tools for Managing StressLoneliness, A Health HazardStress and Depression, Those Monday MorningsCan Mindfulness Make Us More Productive and Happier?Just Breathe: A Practice to Calm the Anxious MindStrategies to Keep Work Stress at BayThe Importance of ForgivenessRescuing and Rejuvenating a Manager at the Bureaucratic Burnout BattlefrontHoliday Stress QuizIt's the Holidays! Four Ways to Calm the Stressed MindNow and Then, Stress Is a Good ThingObesity, An Addiction?Cultivating Patience in Everyday LifeDo Stress Can Kill You Articles Cause You to Worry More? 6 Ways Mindfulness Can Improve Your Daily Life Are Self-Hate and Prejudice Against Others Different?How to be Wise About FearPractice a Self-Care Diet5 Signs of Emotional Exhaustion at Work The Brain in Your GutHow to Relax When Faced With School and Work StressWhat are the Real Roots of Workplace Stress?Some thoughts About Returning to School and LearningStrangers and The Need For Personal SpaceFind StillnessRecognize How Precious Your Life IsHuman Behavior, My Brain Made Me do It?Stress and the Dangers of AlcoholWhen Keeping Calm and Carrying On is Not EnoughHugging is Good MedicineBurnout and (Vicarious) Trauma-Inducing Work Environments: Part IIIProvocation, Anger and ReactionA Mindful Way Through ProcrastinationStress on the Rise? Two Simple Practices to Find ReliefThe Cascade Effect of Emotional StressOn Laughing and LaughterExercise: Building the "Can Do" MuscleWhy Are People in Such a Hurry?On Being OptimisticA 3 Day Plan to Break Free from IrritationDepressed, Forgetful? Take a Walk in the ParkFast Food, Health and DepressionHaving Trouble Exercising? Cultivate a Mindful HabitOlfactory Sensations (Smell) and Stress ReductionAvoid the RushThe Transitional Objects and Self ComfortChange Your Body, Change Your MindStress Reduction, Tropical Fish and AquariumsThe Erosive Grief-Ghost Spiral - Part III: Burnout Exposing the Burn-in...Burn-in Exploding the BurnoutSome Comments on Belief, Religion and Mutual RespectThe Impact of Stress and AngerA Fun and Mindful Way to Transform Your Child's StressBurn-in, Burnout, and Workplace Griefbusting: Part IA Classic Tip for Stress Reduction at Work Leave the Red ZoneHow to Use Mindfulness Meditation in your LifeThe Secret Ingredient to Making Change StickPut Yourself on Your Priority ListResentment vs.ForgivenessTwo Communicational Tools Providing Perspective, Patience and PresenceThe Pain of Breaking Up, Are You Self-Compassionate?Simple Life Wisdom from Comedian Louis C.K.It's the SAD SeasonBreaking Bad Habits in the New YearWant a Healthier Life? The Mindful DietPerception is Everything, Watch Out for Advertising TricksEconomic Difficulty? The Importance of Self-Compassion and Strategy for the HolidaysA Radical Way to Bring More Joy into Your LifeWhy Did this YouTube Video at 3 Million Hits? Step into the Clouds: Relieving StressStay in Shape in 5 Minutes a DayAngst in the Face of Economic Meltdown: Managing Your Anxiety When The Stress Won't Go Away! Part IIAngst in the Face of Economic Meltdown: Managing Your Anxiety When The Stress Won't Go Away! Part IThe Top Seven Sources of Stress and Their RemediesLower the PressureWanting Relief? Find Quiet a Few Minutes a DaySensory Overload, Tension and Stress New Video: Why Women Get StressedNational Debt, Stress and Perception, Is It Really That Bad?Got IBS? Study Says to Try a Little MindfulnessIs Mindfulness Uniquely Buddhist? Psychotherapy: Clarifying Some MisconceptionsThe Benefits of Owning a PetThe Frustration of Arguing About the TruthA Manifesto on Curbing the Technology TrapFeeling Overwhelmed? Take a BreakThe Cycle of Life: War, Peace, Happiness, and...On SuperstitionsThe Frustration of WaitingDrop this Thought in and See What Truth ArisesA Simple Yet Important Phrase to Bring into Your LifeHave You Tried the Freedom Practice? Parents and Coping and the Terrible TwosAnxiety, Worry, Stress: Living in the MomentStress, Emotions and Body ResponseTake My Advice, I'm Not Using ItProfessional Sports, Stress and DepressionMindfulness in Daily LifeI Found That Story Very "Touching"Cortisol: Why You Need to Know About ItRecharging Yourself Through Relationships and Giving to OthersNewly Married Couples and Sexual FrequencyCash Still Tight Around the Holidays? A 3 Step SolutionManaging Holiday Stress: Families + Holidays Do Not Always = Warm and Fuzzy TimesMindfulness, Intuition and the BrainThe Art of Pacing - Live Long and ProsperThe Pleasure, Beauty and Power of MusicDialectical Behavior Therapy Skills that Help Women Survive Stress Mindfulness for Stressed Teens: An Expert Interview With Gina Biegel, MA, LMFTDid You Know? Some Surprising Data about Stress An Expert Interview with Darrin Zeer on Managing Work Stress Where You Need to Look to Change Your LifeMake Your Life as Inconvenient as PossibleHow to Be Sick: A Mindful GuideA Lesson from Psalm 126New Research: Mindfulness and Adolescent Boys A Bit of Humor that Can Change Your DayHow a Flexible Body Makes a Flexible MindThe Mind Traps that Hold Us BackRewiring Your Brain for the Digital Age: A Good Thing?Software to Help with our Web Addictions? Bad Habits: Do You Have a Choice? The Most Important Way to Start Your DayIs the Storm Outside or In Your Mind? Thx: A 1 Minute Exercise Opening to the Space in Your Life: A Needed Reflection12 Hours Unplugged: Cravings, Urges, and Insights Oh My! Saturday: The 12 Hour Unplug Challenge What You Need to Know about the Dangers of Meditating for Relaxation Facebook: Research Shows Your Privacy at RiskThe Link Between Anger and StressNeuroplasticity: The Good, Bad and How it Affects YouUsing Your Brain to Work with Difficult Emotions3 Practical Steps to Making a Happier BrainHow to Find the Wisdom Inside to Mend Your Life Forgot Resolutions Already? 2 Strategies to Get You Back on TrackTrauma: A Mindful DialogueThoughts are Not Facts: A Story Everyone Should KnowHow to Slow Down Your Racing Heartbeat When Feeling AnxiousWhat Everyone Should Know About the Dangers Facebook Poses to Your RelationshipsElisha Goldstein's Top 10 Blog Posts for 2009Your Worry or Your Life? Sensory OverloadDo You Have the "I am a Fraud" Syndrome?An Interview with Elisha Goldstein, Ph.D. on Mindfulness at WorkBeyond Thanksgiving: Your Next Stop...How Your Mind Sabotages Your Best Intentions: 3 Steps to Breaking FreeDepression? Stress? How Sweet they Are? A Dissertation on Dark ChocolateWhat is the Key to Less Stress at Work and Life?4 Steps to Losing the Electronic LeashKeeping You Sane: Do You Need a Day Out? You vs. Procrastination: 1 (Mindful) Secret to Winning the BattleAn Evaluation of Self Help Books and AffirmationsIn a Falling Economy, Trust Your Gut Or Reason? Can Anxiety Be a Good Thing? An Interview with Ilan Meyer, Ph.D, on the Effects of Stress on Minority Mental HealthFeeling Stuck? Two Things You Need to Know to Make a Change Elisha Goldstein's Top 10 Mental Help Blog Posts3 Steps Out of Helplessness 4 Steps to Spiritual Health and Well-BeingDo You engage in Emotional Eating?Hope: Our Greatest Antidepressant5 Factors of Resilience to Engage Today! What About the Good News? The Psychology of Twitter, Mindfulness and Your Mental Health Stress Relief: A Simple FormulaEco-Altruism and Your Mental Health3 Ways to Stay Up in a Depressed Work EnvironmentIts Enough to Make You Sick, News Coverage of the Swine FluLife Feel Overwhelming? Lessons From a DishwasherTax Day: Overcoming Stress 1 Strategy for Everyday Mental HelpTrain Your Mind to Tame Your StressIf you lived here…Unhappy Wife = Unhealthy Life? 5 Ways to Achieve MiseryHow Mindfulness can Help You Walk Away from Stress Today"All Work and No Play Make Jack and Jill Dull...."How this economic recession can pull you into an emotional recession without you even knowing it. 5 key steps that can helpBreaking down Martin Luther King's psychology of faith and how it can help you today...Rising teen anxiety! 4 strategies to help your kid todayCollege Stress and Pets:How this new economy can threaten your family without you even knowing itHandling The Stress of the 2008 Holiday SeasonTinnitus, The Annoying Sound Inside Your Head"Music Hath Charms to Soothe the Savage Breast"How to take advantage of the holidays and stave off stress, anxiety, and depressionFacing Economic Stress: women are taking it harder than men.Itching, Another Example of Mind-Body InteractionHow you can be in the flow of life more often and increase your happinessOne strategy you’ll want to know to be less stressed and more focused at work and life! What does an Iraqi war veteran have to teach you about stress? The mental help of a smile, what's in it for you? Anger…constructive, destructive, or both?Too smart for our own good? How we perpetuate stress and how to change! Stock market crash, mortgage crisis, rising inflation: What you need to know for stress relief and sanity! Liberal morality versus conservative morality: Understanding the difference can help you avoid argumentsWhen will the next addictive trigger hit you? One practice to make sure you’re ready for it. What do Barack Obama and Sarah Palin have to do with your mental health?How stressed out are you? 2 brain nuggets to help you break free today We've all heard of dental floss, but mental floss to prevent stress, anxiety, and depression? TIME OUT! 2 Things you can practice today to stave off anxiety and depression in this hectic time. Is work stress threatening your sanity? This approach will help you make a change now! The X Factor in HappinessThis habitual way of dealing with emotions causes more harm than good; 3 tips to change it now! Coping with the Challenges of Daily StressesNew and Improved Stress Reduction Topic CenterToo Muchness: When Life Gets to Feeling Like it's All Too MuchBurnout, What It Is and What To Do About ItMaintaining Mental Health During the HolidaysStress and Obesity, It's Official: Relaxation is Necessary for HealthI Want to ForgetMen and Anger and Heart Disease RevisitedMeditation: More BenefitsOur Fast Paced LivesWhy Do You Wash the Dishes?Humor Is A Laughing MatterDogs, Social Support and Health: A Winning CombinationA Primer on Coping (and some Holiday applications)Insufficient Arousal - Activation: From Emptiness to Inertia VideosLinksBook Reviews |
| | |
An Evaluation of Self Help Books and AffirmationsAllan Schwartz, LCSW, Ph.D. Updated: Sep 21st 2009 The study:
A study was recently published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science. the study found that self help books and positive affirmations can be damaging. The study was conducted by psychologists at the University of New Brunswick and the University of Waterloo.
The researchers gathered two groups of people, those with low self esteem and those with high self esteem. The members of each group were asked to repeat the self help phrase, "I am lovable." The psychologists then measured their momentary sense of self esteem immediately after repeating the phrase. Those with low self esteem felt worse, and, those with high self esteem, felt better after the reading and repeating the phrase.
The researchers concluded that the low self esteem group felt worse because the expectation of "feeling lovable" was too high for them to believe.
Comment:
If the concept of "Self Help" were as easy as simply repeating self affirming phrases then I could well agree with the conclusions reached by these researchers. However, if anyone examines the excellent "Online Self Help Book" that we have on Mental Help Net, they will find that a lot more is involved than simply repeating fake positive phrases. The URL is here:
http://www.mentalhelp.net/poc/center_index.php?id=353
In fact, any good self help book goes into the entire explanation about Cognitive Behavioral Therapy. CBT is not based on memorizing superficial affirmations that a person cannot and will not believe. Rather, it asks people to examine their thoughts and whether or not those thoughts are based on concrete facts and evidence. Most "automatic" or distorted thoughts are based on very little evidence.
For example, if someone misses the bus on the way to work and concludes "I am just a failure," they can examine the evidence. Looking at that thought and examining ones achievements and failures, they will realize, "oh, I have not been successful at some things but I have been at others." Further examination will help them realize, "Oh, I am just angry with myself for missing the bus, and that happens to everyone sometimes."
This is far from a fake or superficial "affirmation."
The best self help books, as exemplified the one that we have, are based on doing things like using meditation to relieve stress, engaging in deep muscle relaxation, applying CBT methods and other sound practices.
There is no doubt that if this does not succeed in helping a person feel better, then, the next step is psychotherapy. In fact, many times it is better to immediately enter psychotherapy. Finally, self help methods and psychotherapy can blend together very nicely.
It is important that readers use care when learning about the "latest research." I often meet people who quote facts from this study and that. However, not all studies are of equal quality. That is why web sites like Mental Help Net are useful to so many people.
Your comments and questions are encouraged.
Allan N. Schwartz, PhD.
positive self-talk works better for me - confuzzed - Sep 24th 2009
Interesting article, Dr. Alan!!
I know for myself when I was in therapy my therapist insisted I select a positive phrase for myself and then repeat it 500 times a day. I honestly tried to do that, but I found for me the repeating became just an exercise in counting which ended up frustrating me to no end because I kept losing track of how many "affirmations" I had said.
So I stopped, and have found that positive self-talk works better for me that repeating the same phrase over and over and over again. Studies? - Cathy - Sep 22nd 2009
I like the study where they use 40 people and from those they draw conclusions that will effect billions of people - I mean really. The self help book that is referenced is excellent and even if you don't need help, it makes for interesting reading and it is always nice to have something to refer someone to when they tell you about a problem they are looking for help with. Self-help is excellent in any field as long as the person is motivated, of course, if the person isn't motivated you aren't going to get anywhere anyways. I just have one affirmation "they (you, it, she, he) will not steal my joy" - it works! Interesting piece. - JR - Sep 22nd 2009
Thanks, Allan. Having been "through the mill" a bit with this sort of thing, I agree with your comments, from a "consumer" standpoint. I have little doubt that I have benefitted from using some self-help texts - in particular, ones dealing intelligently with CBT and meditation. However, I despair at the scriptures emanating from the "Church of Oprah", many of which give the impression that anybody can self-empower themselves in any way by some simple process, essentially, of self-sloganeering. This is not a case of optimising though - it is more a case of stopping it, in favour of an illusion. It is not just a matter that those most in need of help feel that much of what is promised in these books is impossible - they actually know, deep down, that such texts promise the impossible. The real response is hardly likely to be positive.
It is simply, and patently, not true that anybody can achieve anything, just by persuading themselves or believing this to be true. On the other hand, even the humblest of us can achieve much by identifying our abilities realistically, and employing them in a realistic way.
Thanks again,
JR |