Basic Information More Information Latest News Teen Sexting Can Be Warning Sign of Other Risky Behaviors Tips for Keeping Your Child Healthy at Camp Best Gift From Dad for Kids: More Time Together 'Dad Shaming' Is Real, Survey Shows How to Put Limits on Your Family's Screen Time Hundreds of Young Kids Drown in Pools Each Year -- Keep Yours Safe AHA News: With Summer Vacation Here, How Much Screen Time Is Too Much? How Kids Benefit From Doing Chores Opioid Prescriptions to Teens, Young Adults Still Common Does Taking Screens Away Help Sleep-Deprived Teens? Health Tip: Children and Pets Does Your Sunscreen Work for You? Who's Most Likely to Miss School Due to Eczema? 2 of 3 Parents Read Texts While Driving How to Tame Morning Chaos 3 Parenting Essentials to Safeguard Kids' Well-Being Can Games and Apps Help Your Kids Learn? Teaching Kids the Importance of an Apology How to Stay Close as a Couple Now That Baby Is Here Single Moms Often Put Kids' Health Care First, Study Finds Taking a Bite Out of Food Ads Targeted to Kids Head Off the Blues When Your Teen Heads to College Health Tip: Becoming a Step Parent Health Tip: Talk to Your Kids Early About Alcohol Use The Reality of Watching Reality TV Almost All U.S. Teens Falling Short on Sleep, Exercise Movie Violence Doesn't Make Kids Violent, Study Finds Gay Dads and Their Kids Still Face Social Shaming Parents, Think Before You Drink This Holiday When You Go From a Family of 3 to a Family of 4 Navigating New Parent Nerves Pediatricians Renew Call to Abandon Spanking Try Small 'Bites' to Get Kids to Exercise Health Tip: Connect With Your Child Health Tip: Manage the Terrible 3's How to Prevent Your Child From Getting Bullied -- or Being a Bully Young Adults Favor Family Over Friends If Forced to Choose To Combat Childhood Obesity, Start at Birth … or Even Before Longest Study Yet Finds Adult Kids of Lesbian Moms Are Doing Fine Parent's Tough Childhood Can Cast Shadow Across Generations To Fight Childhood Obesity, Moms to the Rescue Many Parents Say Sports Can Be Too Dangerous for Kids Health Tip: Rules for the Pool Parents Ill-Informed About Kids' Concussion Risks Health Tip: When Kids Have Separation Anxiety Health Tip: Why People Get Ear Infections Health Tip: Buy a Bike That Suits Your Child Clear Rules, Physical Activity Cut Children's Screen Time Vaccination Ends Disparities in Pneumococcal Disease Preventive Intervention for Premature Infants Effective Questions and Answers Blog Entries Navigating Different Types of Conflict Between Parents and Children Curbing Your Child's Texting While Improving Communication Help Your Teen Ease into Early Adulthood The Best Parenting Style for Effective Relationship-Building with Your Children - Part II The Best Parenting Style for Effective Relationship-Building with Your Children - Part I Motivating Adolescents Toward Responsible Choices - Part II Stress Resiliency and Brain Agility through Sleep-Priorities-Passion-Empathy-Exercise-Diet Part II Motivating Adolescents Toward Responsible Choices - Part I Teaching Your Kids to be Smart Consumers Stress Resiliency and Brain Agility through Sleep-Priorities-Passion-Empathy-Exercise-Diet Part I Helping Your Kids Avoid the Trap of Materialism Who’s Coming through the Door Again? Understanding the New Concept of Emerging Adulthood Modeling Behaviors You Want Your Children to Practice How to be an Emotionally Intelligent Parent - Part II Natural SPEED Rap for Kids – Part I: Building Stress Resilience How to be an Emotionally Intelligent Parent - Part I Parents Who Have OCD Applying Empathy in Your Relationship with Your Child BULLY Boy/Girl Ways to Connect with your Child in a Fast-Paced World The Challenges of Parenting in a Time-Starved World Building Up Your Teen's Self-Efficacy - Part II Allowing Adolescents to Make Mistakes - Part I Building Resiliency in Your Child Conscious Parenting Single Dads - Building a Solid Relationship with Your Child How To Reduce Your Child's Texting While Improving Parent/Child Communication I'm a Bully, I'm a Bully: I'm a Bully, You're a Nerdie - Part II Purposeful Parenting Provides Much Needed Direction For Teens I'm a Bully, I'm a Bully: I'm a Bully, You're a Nerdie - Part I 5 Gifts Your Children Will Never Forget Shared Parenting: Making it Work Parent from the Same Page 7 Tips for Effective Communication with Your School-aged Child Lower Your Parenting Stress Three Vital Steps to Repair Parenting Mistakes Three Challenges Parents Face and Ways to Keep Your Relationship with Your Kids Strong Unsociable Teenagers Hardwiring Our Children’s Happiness Of Budget Cuts, Schools and Students 10 Tips for Being a Great Parent Are Popular Kids at School More Successful Later in Life? Pushy Parents Parents Who Cannot Let Go Sports without Numbers: Good or Bad for Kids? Cultivating an Environment to Teach Children Appreciation and Respect For Differences Family Meals and Adolescent Mental Health 10 Tips to Best Mothering and Self-Love When Fear Keeps Kids From School, School Phobia Helping Parents Understand OCD The Helicopter Parent and the Dangers of Over Protecting 5 Habits of Emotionally Intelligent Families Investigating the Complicated Emotional Life of Adolescents Can Parents Teach Their Children to be Empathetic? Teen Rejection Hurts More than the Heart The Importance of Finding Meaning In Life: An Existential Crisis Preventing Childhood Obesity On Being Selfish: Is It All About Me? Warning: Child Centered is not Child Friendly! Are You a Codependent Parent? How to Raise Emotionally Healthy Children What We Can Learn from Our Kids Radical Religious Belief and Child Abuse, "Spare the Rod and Spoil the Child" "Love and Logic" Principles of Parenting Parenting and Child Development, Punishment and Its Result Parenting and Child Development It's a Man's World, or Is It?? Kids are More Stressed than We Realize: 4 Steps to Take Parental Depression and Children Addressing Problems at Schools in Context: A Philosophical Statement Understanding Criticism A Fun and Mindful Way to Transform Your Child's Stress Guns, Gun Control, Violence, Children Who is Changing the Lives of Our Kids? Children and Parental Role Modeling Why It is Important for Our Children to Have Friends An Interview with Joel Bakan on Childhood Under Siege An Interview with John Duffy, Psy.D., on The Available Parent Toddlers and Television: Not A Good Mix An Important Life Lesson from a Dragon Mom Is it OK for Four and Five-Year-Old Boys to Sometimes Dress like Girls? Terrible Toddler Temper Tantrums The Narcissistic Parent Children: A Plea For Fairy Tales, Myths and Legends The Only and Correct Way to Parent The Self Fulfilling Prophecy of Childhood Mental Health Diagnosis Did My Parents Care Too Much? Fathers and Father's Day Toddlers, Toys and Cognitive Development I Had a Perfect Childhood, Why am I Depressed? The Secret to Parenting your Pre-teen Education and Reading and Parenting: "A Picture is Worth a Thousand Words" Managing the Pocketbook of the Facebook Generation: How to Talk to Your Teenager About Finance The Neuroscience of Peer Pressure The Greatest Gift a Parent Can Bestow Upon Their Children “Caregiving for Cerebral Palsy” - A Mother & Daughter Hardship Mother Knows Best - My Son's Mother That Is Stepfamily Success: How Do You Know When You Can Relax? Sad Dads Need Help: Preventative Care for Babies Mindful Parenting: Preventative Care for Children Step Dads, Don’t Expect to Bring Order Into Your New Family A Message to Parents: Relax a Little Talking About Their Generation: Part Three in a Series on Helping Freshman Cope with the Transition to College Strategies for Success for Stepmothers Always Predicting Disaster Talking About Their Generation: Part Two in a Series on Helping Freshman Cope with the Transition to College Talking About Their Generation: Part One in a Series on Helping Freshman Cope with the Transition to College Mindfulness and Youth: The Time is Now The Childhood Anxiety Epidemic: What Parents Can Do About It Parenting: What Happens When Our Subconscious Gets it Wrong? Grandparents Raising Their Grandchildren A Debate Rages Over Education and Parenting Autism and Fraud, Psychopathy Defined, Does Greed Have No limits? Childhood Mental Health Problems and Parental Embarrassment Part 2: How Do Our Young People Communicate Today: What is the Downside and What Can We Do About It? How Do Our Young People Communicate Today: What is the Downside and What Can We Do About It? Part One Student Academic Performance New Child Development Theory: Adolescence Center Available Parenting After Divorce Parents: Are Your Regrets Fact or Fiction? Autistic Disorders and Parental Advocacy An Interview with Daniel Sonkin, Ph.D., on Parents' Reactions To Children Leaving Home Of Babies and Kisses and Hugs The Role Of Mentalization In The Development Of Borderline Personality Disorder Prepare Now: How to Get Teens to Focus with Homework Why Parents Hate Parenting: Or Do They? Parental Suicide and Vulnerable Children New Study: Spanking Promotes Aggression in Kids Parenting, Children, and Observational Learning The Child is Father to the Man What Every Parent Should Know About School Anxiety When Children Steal An Interview with Keith Sutton, Psy.D. on Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD) Calming Your Child's Anxious Mind Divorce: Five Mistakes Made by Divorced Parents. Rising teen anxiety! 4 strategies to help your kid today The Importance of Recognizing Childhood Successes at School Parents of Children with ADHD Stuttering, Inherited? Are Your Children Over-Scheduled and Over-Stressed? The Amazing Story of a Boy Who Would Never Focus on Anything Isolated Mothers and the Challenges of Newborns The Stress of Returning to School On Returning to School and Our Nation Bullying and Suicidal Ideation Linked Among Children On Fathers On Father's Day Some Thoughts on the Importance of Reading to Your Children Happy Mother's Day To All Mothers An Interview with Sarah Chana Radcliffe, M.Ed., C.Psych.Assoc. on Raising Kids without Raising your Voice An Interview with Annie Fox, M.Ed. on Parenting 21st Century Teens An Interview with Amy J. L. Baker, Ph.D. on Parental Alienation Syndrome Teenagers and Sleep, How to Help? Separation Anxiety: A Normal Occurrence for Small Children The End of Vacation, Back to School and Work Young Adolescence, Twelve to Fourteen Years Old Mother's Influence on Psychological and Physical Health Extends to Old Age Teenagers, Their Brains are Different An Interview with Jeff Bernstein, Ph.D. on Defiant Children Helicopter Parents The Negative Consequences of Sexualization of Girls New Infant Safety/Enrichment Material Added To Parenting What Kind of Father Are You? Teachers as Brokers for ADHD Treating Mother's Depression Helps Protect Their Children Videos Links Book Reviews Self-Help Groups
A Debate Rages Over Education and Parenting Allan Schwartz, LCSW, Ph.D. Updated: Jan 19th 2011
Dr. Chua is married and a mother of two daughters who are now around 18 to 19 years old. Based on the premise that American moms are too permissive, she describes how she was strict in the way she raised her children and insisted they strive for the best. They were denied television and video games, had to practice for hours on their piano and were not allowed to have sleep-overs. They were required to study hard for school and complete all of their homework.
The book has received harsh criticism in the United States and sparked a controversy in China. In the United States,Dr. Chua has been accused of being a cruel mother and has even received death threats for her criticism of American moms. In China, many moms have been interviewed and asserted that they are not strict, do not raise their children in the old Chinese traditional style and want their children an educational system that is flexible and does not rely on rote memorization. Chinese educators seem to agree, preferring Western styles of education so that children can learn to think for themselves and be creative and problem solving thinkers.
On the other hand, Dr. Chua's daughter states that they are happy about the way they were raised. They assert that mom did insist on performance and was strict, but that home life was happy. In an article published in the New York Post, the older daughter reports her belief that it is important to push yourself hard in body and mind. As an example, she describes how, when working hard on the piano and the music comes alive under your fingers, its a life changing event.
What are your opinions about this? Was Dr. Chua too strict? As parents, adults and teenagers, what were your learning experiences at home and in school? are we too permissive in the United States and Western Europe?
This is an important discussion because this debate rager her in the United States where concerned parents, teachers and leaders worry about our children and why they do not seem to academic performance in science and math has slipped compared to other nations.
Your comments are strongly anticipated. Please respond.
Allan N. Schwartz, PhD
RSS Feed
Amy Chua is a professor of law at the Yale University. Author of many books, her newest if titled, "Battle Hymn of The Tiger Mom." In it she gives a scathing criticism of American moms, their rearing practices and their attitudes towards children's the education of their children. In her book she boldly states that Chinese moms are superior to American moms.
