Mental Help Net
Depression: Depression & Related Conditions
Basic Information
Introduction and Types of Depressive DisordersRelated Disorders / ConditionsHistorical and Current UnderstandingsBiology, Psychology and SociologyTreatment - Medication and PsychotherapyAlternative Medicine and Self-Help ResourcesSpecial IssuesReferences
More InformationTestsLatest NewsQuestions and AnswersBlog EntriesVideosLinksBook Reviews
Therapist Search
Find a Therapist:
 (USA/CAN only)

Use our Advanced Search to locate a therapist outside of North America.

Related Topics

Anxiety Disorders
Bipolar Disorder
Addictions: Alcohol and Substance Abuse
Pain Management
View the Depression Primer - an illustrated book about Depression

Allan Schwartz, Ph.D.Allan Schwartz, Ph.D.
Dr. Schwartz's Weblog

Dogs, Depression and Other Health Issues: Is there something to be gained from Illness?

Allan N. Schwartz, LCSW, Ph.D. Updated: Oct 1st 2007

My wife trains dogs for people with depression, phobias and other psychiatric problems. These dogs, mostly Labrador Retrievers and Golden Retrievers, have been very successful in helping those with mental illnesses to get out of the house and function. By the way, they are referred to as Psychiatric Service (Assistance) Dogs. It seems the mere presence of the dog has a calming effect on those people who, previous to having a dog, could not function at all. In addition, the dogs are trained to respond to the changing moods of the client and provide the necessary attention and reassurance. But, for some people can there be too much of a good thing? Here is an interesting piece of a case that has been totally disguised so as to protect privacy and identity:


"A middle aged man who is now a widow and living alone in some place USA has been extremely depressed since the loss of his wife. He has no children, no friends and no life. His mental illness has been so severe that he is on permanent disability and lives in public housing. His medical doctor referred him for psychiatric and psychotherapeutic services and these have been only moderately successful in relieving his depression. He heard about the use of psychiatric service dogs acting as companions and assistants for those with a variety of disabilities, from physical to emotional. When he mentioned the possibility of such a dog helping this patient, the man became enthusiastic, something unusual for him. A company that trains and provides such dogs (my wife's company) was contacted and the appointment was set up. Lest there be any doubt, the man's psychiatrist and psychotherapist fully endorsed this patient getting such a dog.

To jump ahead to the main issue, after a good deal of training for the dog and for the patient in learning how to handle and care for such a dog, and after he and the dog passed the necessary licensing tests, the patient and his dog settled down into a much improved life for this man. Now, with a dog, there was no way for him to stay in the house alone. Besides being a wonderful companion for the patient, he also had to frequently walk the dog and this caused him to meet people who regularly stopped to speak to him and the dog.

Also, with the dog he could shop in supermarkets, shopping centers, eat in restaurants, fly in air planes and even use buses with the dog. Fully licensed, both man and dog wore ID which entitled them to go anywhere they wished.

Then, one day, my wife got a complaint from the man. His complaint was that the dog did not allow him to wallow in depression and self pity! Alert to his master's moods, the dog was quick to respond by jumping on the man's lap and encouraging petting and hugging. On this particular day, the man became frustrated because 'he did no want to feel better!' "


Why would someone not want to feel better? Is such a thing possible? How can it be explained?

There are multiple explanations for depression and its causes that range from a chemical imbalance in the brain to learned helplessness and learned hopelessness. None of the explanations are mutually exclusive so that there can be a combination of factors causing depression. These overlapping causes can be a chemical imbalance in the brain along with learning to be and feel hopeless and helpless.

How can depression be learned? There were a number of fascinating experiments years ago that included the use of electric shocks delivered to a variety of animals from dogs to rats. When the shocked dogs had a place in the cage they could escape to in order to end and avoid the electric shock they made normal adjustments. However, those animals that had no escape route from the electric shocks became hopeless and depressed even if there cage was later changed and there was room to escape shocks. These latter dogs remained in the electrified part of the cage because they had learned that escape was hopeless.

There was a time when psychoanalysts referred to this phenomenon in people as "secondary gain." A secondary gain is defined as wanting to remain neurotic, depressed and anxious because it was rewarding to remain sick.

Many years ago when I was interning at a psychiatric day hospital for acutely ill psychotic patients we learned that people are often fearful of giving up their mental illness, even if it is psychosis, because it is all they have ever known. In other words, for some people sickness feels so comfortable that it is threatening to learn to be normal or healthy. One ADHD adult man who refuses medication but is successful at work, refuses medication because it frightened him to think of being any other way than they way he is now.

With this explanation in mind, it is not so surprising to learn that the depressed patient in the case above became annoyed with his dog. On that particular day he preferred to continue to feel hopeless and helpless. He had felt this way for so many years that the new and healthy way of being, without depression was not quite normal for this man.

It is nice to report that this patient was able to gain new learnings and function in the world as a much happier and content individual.

It is normal to believe that people want to feel better. However, like most things about human nature, the truth is complicated.

Your comments are welcome and encouraged.

Allan Schwartz, LCSW, Ph.D.

Readers who live in the Boulder, Colorado metro area, or in Southwest Florida may contact Dr. Schwartz for face-to-face consultation. He is also available for psychotherapy through Skype video for those who are not in Florida or Colorado. He can be reached via email at for details.

Reader Comments
Discuss this issue below or in our forums.

Yes - it could be VERY complicated - B Zoe - Sep 13th 2010

Has it crossed anyone's mind that this patient has come to consider that he may be becoming too dependent upon his service dog for comfort & happiness?  Couldn't it be possible that he is smart enough to realize that it isn't a good gamble to become so obsessively dependent upon just one thing to rescue him from unhappy feelings forever? Allowing himself to recognize that endulging his "old feelings" which he had achieved some level of comfort with, may actually may help him to know that he can tolerate them on his own.  Denying himself total dependency on his dog may actually help him to cope with the idea (or belief) that there may come a day when his dog is no longer there. Some people believe that being "TOO much in love" only sets them up for a deep dis- appointment (e.g. depression) somewhere down the line. It's not that he doubts his dog's unconditional love, but that he worries he may become way too dependent upon it

another possibility - have had depression twice - Jan 19th 2010

Are you sure the patient didn't mean that he simply didn't want to feel better in that moment, as opposed to not wanting to ever recover from depression?

It seems perfectly normal to me that he might not always want to be cheered up. 

Sometimes when you're sad, you just need to let yourself feel the sadness. I mean, who hasn't ever declined an invitation from a friend because he or she felt crummy?--even though most of us can recognize that seeing the friend would probably make us feel better?

There are times when you just want to be left alone for a while.

Fears Galore - - Oct 8th 2007
     I haven't done any research on the subject, but could there be part of the patient, who appears to enjoy staying ill, actually be frozen in the same position, he has been in for so many years, because he has so many fears from every direction and every angle of life?  I have suffered depression ever since I can remember, for 67 years, and I do not feel anyone or any program, has ever been able to help me feel "healed".  But I do know that I am frightened by nearly everything.  I compare myself with others and things that cause me concern and distress, don't seem to faze others.  But, I do hate being like this.  My stress level is sky high, and of course, my physical health shows the results of it too.  It may not be the fact the patient "enjoys" being sick but is overwhelmed from every direction by all of these fears, which came, for me, by never having a feeling of security, or feelings of protection or caring when growing up and nor any security, feelings of protection, having someone in my corner, or caring just for me in my marriage, as I was  taught I should feel.  When you have few coping skills, most of your time is spent trying to face off the fears, which are coming at you constantly.  At the same time, you are desperately trying to act normal, when you don't really know what normal is.  It is very painful to take those first steps into life, as you have never experienced life before.    I don't know if this makes any sence to you or someone who has not suffered with severe depression, but is one reason I am fearful to make any new steps or try new things because of the insecurity from all the fears.

Follow us on Twitter!

Find us on Facebook!

This website is certified by Health On the Net Foundation. Click to verify.This site complies with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health information:
verify here.

Powered by CenterSite.Net